Is Arcadia South Actually Better Than Arcadia Bluffs?

When it comes to the best golf courses in Michigan, Arcadia Bluffs Golf Club consistently tops the list. Renowned for its breathtaking views of Lake Michigan, challenging layout, and world-class amenities, this Michigan golf resort has earned its reputation as a bucket-list destination for golfers. But with the addition of the Arcadia South Course, a debate has emerged: Is Arcadia South actually better than the iconic Arcadia Bluffs? At Metro Detroit Golfers, we’re diving into this question, comparing these two stellar courses. Check out the embedded video

below where Mike Sullivan and Kyle Bogenschutz share their expert opinions!

The Legendary Arcadia Bluffs Golf Course

Opened in 1999, the Arcadia Bluffs Golf Course is a masterpiece designed by Warren Henderson and Rick Smith. Perched on 245 windswept acres along Lake Michigan, this seaside links-style course drops 225 feet from its highest point to the bluffs, 180 feet above the lake, offering 3,100 feet of stunning shoreline views. With rolling terrain, natural fescues, and 50 revetted bunkers, it’s no wonder Arcadia Bluffs is often ranked the best public golf course in Michigan and a top contender among the best in the U.S. The fairways are wide, the greens average 8,000 square feet, and the wind off Lake Michigan adds a thrilling challenge. Signature holes like the 240-yard par-3 13th, with its canyon carry to a cliff-edge green, and the dramatic par-4 12th along the bluff make it unforgettable. Paired with exceptional lodging and dining, this Michigan golf resort delivers a complete experience.

The Rise of Arcadia South Course

Introduced in 2018, the Arcadia South Course, designed by Dana Fry and Jason Straka, offers a contrasting yet complementary experience. Located a mile inland, this 311-acre layout draws inspiration from Golden Age architects C.B. Macdonald and Seth Raynor, channeling the strategic spirit of Chicago Golf Club. Unlike the visually striking Arcadia Bluffs, the South Course prioritizes intellect over eye candy. Wide fairways, large greens (averaging 9,400 square feet), and bold, grass-faced bunkers create a firm, fast, and strategic test. Features like squared-off greens, centerline hazards, and alternate routes of play demand thoughtful shot-making. While it lacks Lake Michigan views, the rolling topography and wind exposure keep it challenging and fun, earning it a spot among Michigan’s top public golf courses.

Comparing the Two: Bluffs vs. South

So, is Arcadia South better than Arcadia Bluffs? It depends on what you value. The Arcadia Bluffs Golf Course is a visual feast, with panoramic Lake Michigan vistas from nearly every hole, making it a must-play for those seeking the ultimate Michigan golf resort experience. Its rugged dunes, elevation changes, and links-style design test all skill levels, cementing its status as the best course in Michigan for many. Conversely, Arcadia South appeals to golfers who enjoy strategic depth. Its throwback design, with unique greens and bunkering, rewards clever play over raw power. Both courses are impeccably maintained, but the Bluffs’ dramatic setting often overshadows the South’s subtle brilliance.

What Metro Detroit Golfers Think

In our embedded video, Mike Sullivan and Kyle Bogenschutz break down their experiences. Mike praises Arcadia Bluffs for its jaw-dropping views and challenging layout, calling it a “bucket-list gem.” Kyle leans toward Arcadia South, appreciating its strategic variety and playability. Both agree: you can’t go wrong at this premier Michigan golf resort.

Verdict: Which Is Better?

Neither course is definitively “better”—they’re different. For stunning scenery and a classic links challenge, Arcadia Bluffs Golf Course remains the best public golf course in Michigan. For a cerebral, Golden Age-inspired round, Arcadia South shines. Plan a trip to Arcadia Bluffs Golf Club, play both, and decide for yourself! Book your tee time and stay at this top Michigan golf resort for an unforgettable adventure.